Unofficial fan site · Not affiliated with the band

Sound & instruments

Left, right and between: hearing stereo space

A spatial sketch of a recording is not a plan of the stage.

Benjamin Kowalewicz — Rock am Ring 2016
Benjamin Kowalewicz — Rock am Ring 2016. Contextual photograph; not documentation of a particular song or of other events discussed. © Sven Mandel · Image source · CC BY-SA 4.0 · Web-sized

A stereo recording distributes sound across two channels. That can create a perception of left, right and centre without giving every instrument a sharply bounded position. For a session with Dead Silence, begin with a familiar passage. Special equipment is unnecessary, but know whether your device reproduces the channels separately or combines them through a mono setting. The playback condition affects what the experiment can tell you.

Draw with soft boundaries

Make a wide line on paper and mark only left, middle and right. Add a few conspicuous sound events while listening. Use circles or areas rather than exact points where something seems broad or indistinct. The drawing describes your perception; it is not a technical analysis. It may change when attention moves to another layer. That flexibility makes it more useful than pretending every sound has an objectively fixed coordinate you must discover.

Headphones and speakers can create different impressions. With speakers, each ear also receives sound from the opposite speaker, and the room contributes. Headphones create another situation. If switching between them, describe the changed conditions as well as the result. The spatial effect cannot be fully separated from the playback route. A difference does not automatically identify a flaw in either device. It may reflect how the same recording reaches you.

Position does not establish identity

A sound on the left does not prove the musician stood on the left of the recording room. A mix can construct spatial relationships. Likewise, a broad guitar image does not establish that two guitarists performed simultaneously. Those claims would require credits or production information. A spatial description is interesting in its own right and need not be attached to a reconstructed studio story. What you can hear and how it was made remain separate questions.

On another pass, follow changes rather than fixed positions. Does a passage seem wider, does the centre become more occupied, or does one sound move into attention? Describe that as an impression rather than an exact measurement. Avoid raising the level substantially to inspect one channel. If trying a balance control, remain at a comfortable level and return it to the normal position afterwards. The aim is to understand relationships, not uncover detail through excessive volume.

Finally hear the passage as a whole again. The sketch should not leave the music divided permanently into isolated objects. The useful question is how distribution creates relationships: closeness, distance, overlap or a shared centre. A stereo image is not a map of the band. It is a property of the released presentation that can be described without unsupported conclusions about the actual arrangement of people in a studio or on stage. That distinction makes the result clearer, not less valuable.

Keep reading